Selena Gomez, Martin Short, and Steve Martin Return for Only Murders in the Building Season 5: Full Cast & Plot Guide

Fans of mystery, humor, and quirky neighborly drama have reason to celebrate — Only Murders in the Building is officially returning for its highly anticipated Season 5. The hit Hulu comedy, which masterfully blends murder-mystery intrigue with sharp comedic timing, is bringing back its beloved central trio — Selena Gomez, Martin Short, and Steve Martin — and promises a fresh web of secrets, new characters, and jaw-dropping twists.

The Series So Far — Why It Clicks with Audiences

Since its debut in 2021, Only Murders in the Building has carved a niche in the streaming world by merging classic whodunit elements with satirical humor. Set in New York City’s upscale Arconia building, the story follows three true-crime enthusiasts who find themselves solving real murders happening in their own residence.

• Season 1 introduced the trio and set the tone with the mysterious death of Tim Kono.

• Season 2 delved into the murder of Bunny Folger and deeper backstories of the residents.

• Season 3 took the investigation to Broadway, with Paul Rudd and Meryl Streep joining the ensemble.

Each season has raised the stakes, leaving fans guessing until the final moments.

Season 5 — What We Know So Far

While Hulu is keeping certain plot points tightly under wraps, insiders hint that Season 5 will open with the shocking events teased in the Season 4 finale. The new season will reportedly explore multiple timelines, weaving past secrets into the present mystery.

Confirmed returning cast:

• Selena Gomez as Mabel Mora — The stylish, sharp-witted millennial with a knack for puzzles.

• Steve Martin as Charles-Haden Savage — The veteran TV actor who brings his quirky charm and unexpected insight.

• Martin Short as Oliver Putnam — The flamboyant Broadway director whose eccentricity often hides keen detective instincts.

New faces expected to join Season 5 include Emmy-winning actors and a surprise cameo from a global pop star, according to early casting leaks.

The Mystery at the Heart of Season 5

Rumors suggest this season’s central crime will challenge the trio like never before. Instead of a murder contained to the Arconia or its immediate surroundings, the mystery could span multiple locations across New York City, requiring them to leave their comfort zone. Expect new suspects, intertwining subplots, and a final twist that redefines their bond.

Why This Show Stands Out

Unlike other murder-mystery shows that rely solely on suspense, Only Murders in the Building thrives because of its character chemistry. Gomez, Short, and Martin bring generational contrast and comedic brilliance, making the series equally binge-worthy for both young and older audiences. Its playful yet smart narrative, combined with visually rich cinematography, keeps it fresh every season.

When and Where to Watch

Season 5 is expected to premiere later in 2025 exclusively on Hulu in the U.S., with international viewers able to stream it via Disney+ under the Star banner. Fans can catch up on previous seasons now on Hulu or Disney+.

Final Word

With a mix of returning favorites, fresh faces, and a storyline that’s more ambitious than ever, Only Murders in the Building Season 5 looks set to keep audiences hooked from the first clue to the final reveal. Whether you’re here for the mystery, the comedy, or the undeniable charm of Gomez, Short, and Martin, this season promises to be a highlight of 2025 television.